Any list of the best restaurants in Paso Robles has to include Deborah’s Room, so when we recently had the chance to stay at the JUST Inn Bed and Breakfast where it’s located, we had to splurge and treat ourselves to dinner there. It’s an intimate and highly-acclaimed fine dining experience, we’d read, but was it really one of the best restaurants in Paso Robles? Would it justify the spending spree?
We were so glad we’d booked a table to dine in Deborah’s Room for two main reasons. One, it rained torrentially that night and driving to and from dinner somewhere else on wine country back roads would have been miserable. And two, it turned out to be probably the best meal we’ve ever eaten anywhere in California.
That is some claim, but we stand by it. We’ve dined at many gourmet restaurants around the USA and in Europe, including some with the ultimate Three Michelin Stars. In our view the quality of the food at Deborah’s Room was easily Two Michelin Stars. How do they do it? Although the restaurant is open to non-residents, there are nights when it only caters to the inn’s guests – and the inn only has four rooms. On the midweek night we dined, there was just ourselves and one other guest. Our guess is that on quiet nights like this the kitchen runs at a loss but diners get the kitchen’s undivided attention, which is only one reason it ranks as one of the best restaurants in Paso Robles.
If we were splurging on the meal we thought we may as well go the whole hog and enjoy the wine pairings too, which was an extra $45 per person to match a different JUSTIN wine to each of the five courses. For $75 you could also try their superior JUSTIN Isosceles Flight. In practice, the waiter was generous with the servings and slipped in an extra wine when we mentioned that we were fans of tempranillo.
We started with an amuse-bouche which combined scallops, pork belly, petite tangerine, and micro greens – a surprising and wonderful combination of flavours. To go with the freshly-baked bread there were three different types of butter, including an unusual white butter from Canada and a gorgeous thick and creamy butter from Vermont.
The 5-Course Dinner offers three choices for each course, and to begin with Donna had the English Pea Soup with Parmesan Sformato and White Truffle Oil while Mike chose the Sonoma Foie Gras with a Pineapple Upside Down Cake. Both were heavenly. Wine Pairing: 2009 JUSTIN Chardonnay.
We could have had the Butter-Poached Lobster but thought that might be a little rich, with five courses to get through, so Donna chose the Alaskan Halibut with Potato Confit, Yellow Curry, and Wilted Gem Lettuce, while Mike’s Loch Duart Salmon with Anasazi Beans, Spinach, Red-Eye Gravy, and Smoked Ikura Roe was as fresh and as tasty as if it had been hauled out of the loch that evening. Wine Pairing: 2009 JUSTIN Viognier
We skipped the Plantation Quail and for the meat course chose a Colorado Lamb Sirloin Chop (Donna) and the C.A.B. ‘Natural’ Brisket (Mike). The portions were ideal – generous but not too filling, given there was still cheese and dessert to come. In both cases the meat was melt-in-the-mouth perfect, and by now we were definitely in foodie heaven, in a little cocoon while the rain continued to beat down outside. Wine Pairing: 2008 JUSTIN Justification.
There was only one cheese option, a Black River Gorgonzola, which was served with cress, citrus madelines, and some pink peppercorns. It shows confidence to limit the choice and effectively say: this is one good cheese. And it was. Wine Pairing: 2008 JUSTIN Savan
As a fan of both eating and making risotto, Mike was keen to discover what the Arborio Rice Pudding with Pistachio, Morello Cherries and Basil was like. Donna was tempted by the Warm Chocolate Cake with Ganache, Caramelized Cocoa Nibs, and an Orange-Vanilla Sherbet. Yet again, after just one mouthful we felt like standing up and applauding the kitchen, so perfect was the blend of tastes and textures. Wine Pairing: a choice of the 2009 JUSTIN Deborah’s Delight or the 2008 JUSTIN Obtuse.
Well, if there’s a better fine dining restaurant anywhere in Paso Robles wine country, then please let us know about it for our next visit. We can only repeat what we said above – this is not only one of the best restaurants in Paso Robles, but gave us one of the best meals we’ve ever had anywhere in California.
Nov 28, 17 10:28 AM
From the world’s largest surf competition to the biggest corgi celebration, here is our pick of some of the top Huntington Beach Events in 2018.
Nov 16, 17 11:44 AM
Pacific Coast Highway Travel's website recommendations on Where to Stay in Carmel include reviews of the Mission Ranch, Sea View Inn, The Cypress Inn, Lamp Lighter Inn and Vagabond's House Inn.
Nov 16, 17 11:40 AM
This Carmel dog-friendly hotel, the historic Cypress Inn, is co-owned by movie legend Doris Day and offers luxury lodgings for pet-loving travelers (cats welcome too) in Carmel-by-the-Sea.
Follow Us on Twitter
To help you in choosing your Pacific Coast Highway hotel, guesthouse, inn, bed-and-breakfast, resort, motel or other accommodations, we've prepared our Pacific Coast Highway Hotels Guide. In it we do mini-reviews of accommodations along the Highway, from Seattle to San Diego, through Washington, Oregon, and California.
In all there are over 200 hotels listed, complete with 8 pages of color maps showing the towns where our recommended hotels can be found. There are both alphabetical and geographical indexes, helping you plan your journey.
We also include color photos of all the hotels that are our Personal Favorites. Here's the link to read more about our ebook guide to Pacific Coast Highway hotels.
The 2016 edition of our Hotels Guide is available with maps and color photos (if you have a color reader) in the US Kindle Store for only $4.99 and in the UK Kindle Store and other Kindle stores worldwide at prices based on the US price.
If you want a paperback edition of the 2016 guide with only black and white photos and black-and-white maps, it costs $6.99 at the US Amazon Book Store and £4.99 in the UK Amazon Store.