Best Places to Eat in Eureka

Pacific Coast Highway Travel picks the best places to eat in Eureka including bistros, diners, fine dining & places to enjoy the town’s excellent fresh seafood.

Eureka, California may be tucked away on the rugged Northern California coast, but its culinary scene is anything but sleepy. From intimate bistros with wood-fired ovens to waterfront seafood havens, Eureka offers a rich tapestry of flavors and atmospheres.

The Humboldt Bay Bistro in Eureka

Here are some of the best restaurants in town, each with its own distinct vibe and standout dish.

Best Places to Eat in Eureka

1. Brick & Fire Bistro

The Brick & Fire Bistro in Eureka

Brick & Fire Bistro is a warm, intimate spot that feels like a rustic European hideaway. With its exposed brick walls, flickering candles, and the aroma of a wood-fired oven wafting through the air, it’s the kind of place that invites lingering conversations and slow sips of wine.

The menu leans Italian with a California twist, and the wild mushroom cobbler is a local legend—earthy, creamy, and baked to perfection in a cast-iron skillet. Whether you're here for a romantic dinner or a celebratory meal, Brick & Fire delivers cozy elegance with every bite.

📍 1630 F St, Eureka, CA 95501
📞 (707) 268-8959
🌐 brickandfirebistro.com

2. Café Waterfront

The Cafe Waterfront

Located in a historic building near the bay, Café Waterfront exudes old-school charm with its vintage wood paneling, nautical décor, and laid-back vibe. It’s the kind of place where locals gather for fresh oysters and cold beer while watching the fishing boats roll in.

The atmosphere is casual but timeless, with a small oyster bar and friendly staff who know their seafood. One of the standout dishes is the halibut, pan-seared and served with seasonal vegetables and a lemon butter sauce that’s both bright and indulgent.

📍 102 F St, Eureka, CA 95501
📞 (707) 443-9190
🌐 facebook.com

3. Five Eleven

The Five Eleven Restaurant/Bar in Eureka

Five Eleven brings a modern, urban sensibility to Eureka’s historic downtown. Housed in a sleek, art-filled space with high ceilings and contemporary lighting, it’s a favorite for date nights and upscale gatherings.

The menu is New American, with inventive cocktails and seasonal ingredients. Their signature duck breast—served with blackberry gastrique and creamy polenta—is a masterclass in flavor balance. The ambiance is chic but approachable, with attentive service and a curated wine list that complements the bold flavors on the plate.

📍 511 2nd St, Eureka, CA 95501
📞 (707) 798-6091
🌐 fiveeleveneureka.com

4. Adel's Restaurant

Adel's Restaurant in Eureka

Adel’s is a nostalgic throwback to classic American diners, complete with vinyl booths, neon signage, and a menu that spans hearty breakfasts to satisfying dinners. The atmosphere is relaxed and family-friendly, with a touch of retro charm that makes you feel like you’ve stepped into the 1980s.

Their chicken-fried steak is a crowd favorite—crispy on the outside, tender inside, and smothered in rich country gravy. Whether you're fueling up for a road trip or catching up with friends over pancakes, Adel’s is comfort food central.

📍 1724 Broadway St, Eureka, CA 95501
📞 (707) 445-9910
🌐 adelsrestaurant.shop

5. Humboldt Bay Provisions

Enjoying fresh local oysters at Humboldt Bay Provisions

This rustic-chic oyster bar is a celebration of local bounty, with reclaimed wood décor, and a relaxed yet refined vibe. Humboldt Bay Provisions is all about showcasing the best of the region—fresh oysters, local wines, and craft kombucha.

The broiled oysters, topped with garlic butter and herbs, are a must-try and pair beautifully with a crisp white wine. It’s the perfect spot for a casual afternoon tasting or a laid-back evening with friends, all while soaking in the flavors of the California coast.

📍 205 G St, Eureka, CA 95501
📞 (707) 672-3850
🌐 humboldtbayprovisions.us

6. Humboldt Bay Bistro

Sample dessert at the Humboldt Bay Bistro

Set in a renovated Victorian home with views of the water, Humboldt Bay Bistro offers a refined dining experience that blends French homestyle cooking with California flair. The interior is elegant yet intimate, with white tablecloths, soft lighting, and bay windows that frame the sunset.

Their signature dish, the duck à l’orange, is a nod to classic French cuisine—crispy skin, tender meat, and a citrus glaze that’s both sweet and savory. Ideal for special occasions or romantic dinners, this bistro is Eureka’s answer to continental sophistication.

📍 1436 2nd St, Eureka, CA 95501
📞 (707) 443-7339
🌐 humboldtbaybistro.com

7. Sea Grill

Sample dish at the Sea Grill in Eureka

Sea Grill is housed in a beautifully restored 19th-century building, and its interior reflects that timeless elegance—dark wood accents, vintage chandeliers, and a refined atmosphere that feels both classic and upscale.

Known for its premium seafood and steak offerings, the restaurant’s nut-crusted halibut with beurre blanc sauce is a standout. The dish is rich, delicate, and perfectly cooked, showcasing the kitchen’s mastery of technique. Whether you're celebrating a milestone or simply indulging in a fine meal, Sea Grill delivers with grace and flavor.

📍 316 E St, Eureka, CA 95501
📞 (707) 443-7187
🌐 seagrilleureka.com

8. Café Marina & Woodley's Bar

At the aptly-named Cafe Marina in Eureka

Perched right on the harbor, Café Marina offers unbeatable views and a relaxed, nautical vibe. The patio is the star here—perfect for sipping a Bloody Mary while watching the boats drift by. Inside, the décor is maritime-themed with ship wheels, fishing nets, and cozy booths.

Their clam chowder is a local favorite—creamy, briny, and packed with tender clams. It’s the kind of place where you can kick back after a day of exploring and enjoy fresh seafood in a laid-back setting.

📍 601 Startare Dr, Eureka, CA 95501
📞 (707) 443-2234
🌐 cafemarina.net

9. Lost Coast Brewery & Café

Burgers and fries at the Lost Coast Brewery and Cafe in Eureka

Lost Coast Brewery is a lively, colorful spot that combines great beer with hearty pub fare. The interior is whimsical, with murals, beer-themed décor, and a bustling energy that makes it a favorite among locals and tourists alike.

Their fish and chips are legendary—crispy, golden, and served with house-made tartar sauce. Pair it with a pint of their Great White or Downtown Brown for the full experience. It’s casual, fun, and perfect for a laid-back lunch or evening out.

📍 617 4th St, Eureka, CA 95501
📞 (707) 445-4480
🌐 lostcoast.com

10. Gill’s By The Bay

Gill's by the Bay Restaurant in King Salmon near Eureka

Gill's by the Bay in King Salmon near Eureka

Just south of Eureka on the bay at King Salmon, Gill’s By The Bay is a hidden gem with panoramic views of the water and a coastal vibe. The interior is simple and welcoming, with nautical touches and large windows that let in the light.

Their Sandy Beach sandwich—grilled shrimp, avocado, and aioli on a toasted roll—is a standout, especially when paired with their creamy clam chowder. It’s a peaceful spot for breakfast or lunch, where the food is fresh and the scenery is unbeatable.

📍 77 Halibut Ave, King Salmon, CA 95503
📞 (707) 442-2554
🌐 gillsbythebay.com

Our Pick of the Northern California Guides

Whether you're craving wood-fired pizza, fresh oysters, or a perfectly seared steak, Eureka’s dining scene has something to satisfy every palate.eur

Eureka Hotels

Other Eureka Pages

Eureka
Pacific Coast Highway Travel describes Eureka in California, including its history, location, climate, beaches, and things to do.
Best Time to Visit Eureka
Pacific Coast Highway travel picks the best time to visit Eureka, with a month-ny-month breakdown of the likely weather, hotel prices and any special events.
Eureka Inns
Of all Eureka inns, The Carter House Inns are the most romantic and historic, with one of the best restaurants in Northern California.